Looking for the top restaurants on Orcas Island? Look no further! Nestled in the heart of the Salish Sea, Orcas Island, the largest of the San Juan Islands in Washington State, is a paradise for food lovers. With its lush landscapes, fresh local produce, and thriving culinary scene, Orcas Island offers a gastronomic adventure that's as diverse and vibrant as its stunning natural beauty. Let’s take a look at some of our most-recommended stops during your stay!
Laid-Back Casual Dining
During the summertime, one of our favorite locations for a waterfront dinner is Rosario Resort and Spa’s marina dining spot, the Cascade Bay Grill. This outdoor dining restaurant is situated just above the Resort Marina. Here, you’ll enjoy great meals, cool breezes with views of sailboats, yachts, and the occasional seaplane. Weekends often provide live music during dinner hours in this casual, laid-back atmosphere.
Outdoor Dining at the Cascade Grill at Rosario Resort
Seafood Delights
Being surrounded by the bountiful waters of the Salish Sea, Orcas Island boasts an array of seafood that's as fresh as it gets. From succulent Dungeness crab to world-class Pacific salmon, the island's seafood offerings are a must-try for any food enthusiast.
Madrona Bar & Grill offers stunning waterfront views and a menu packed with fresh seafood options, with a Crab Bisque that you’ll wish you ordered a bowl instead of a cup!
Buck Bay Shellfish Farm is a must-visit for a well-rounded seafood menu with glorious picnic-style outdoor seating on their grounds with trees offering an escape from the sun during the summer. From oysters on the half-shell to their delicate Halibut Fish and Chips, you’re bound to find an item on the menu for all seafood lovers.
Fresh Oysters at Buck Bay Shellfish Farm
The Best Brunch Around
The New Leaf Cafe is a local favorite for brunch. Located directly across from the beautiful scenery of Ship Bay and Indian Island in Eastsound, guests are welcomed to an amazing water view with a menu to match. Several dishes include the “New Leaf Potatoes” - delicate pieces of double-fried and seasoned to perfection, including our go-to upon each visit, the Classic Eggs Benedict.
For the adventurous foodies in your group, the Crispy Confit Duck Leg Belgian Waffle with Pancetta Lardon and chili-infused maple syrup is a must-try!
Eggs Benedict at the New Leaf Cafe
A Taste of the World
Despite our remote location, Orcas Island's culinary scene is surprisingly cosmopolitan. You can find everything from rustic Italian cuisine to authentic Mexican fare, all prepared with a unique Orcas Island twist.
Mijitas Mexican Kitchen offers exquisite Mexican-inspired cuisine for dinner with beautiful outdoor seating located directly across from the Village Green in Eastsound.
Be sure to try the Dungeness Crab Guacamole!
Meal from Mijita’s Mexican Kitchen
Artisanal Offerings
Orcas Island is also home to a variety of artisanal producers. From handcrafted cheeses and freshly baked bread to locally made wines and craft beers, the island is a treasure trove of culinary delights waiting to be discovered. Orcas Island Winery offers a selection of wines in a beautiful setting, both inside and out.
But a must-visit in the heart of Eastsound Village is Brown Bear Baking. Step inside this bustling bakery and feast your eyes on the every-changing selections in the display case. Be sure to get something to go, or you’ll have to brave the line that’s likely out the door and down the sidewalk once again…. but trust us, it’s worth the wait!
Display Case from the Brown Bear Baking never disappoints
A Welcoming Atmosphere
Above all, Orcas Island's restaurant scene is characterized by its warm, welcoming atmosphere. Whether you're dining at a high-end restaurant or a cozy café, you'll be treated to friendly service, stunning views, and a dining experience that's truly unforgettable.
On the East side of the island, Doe Bay Cafe offers a range of dining options in a serene, natural setting. For a truly unique dining experience, don't miss Kingfish at West Sound, an intimate waterfront restaurant known for its creative menu and stunning views of West Sound from its dining room and outside deck seating.
The Lower Tavern is a beloved local watering hole with a friendly vibe with several Televisions showing the games of the season. The Black & Blue Burger and a side of Wings is always a favorite, especially when it’s “To-Go” and enjoyed with a view from the picnic tables at the nearby Eastsound Waterfront Park.
Wings and Burger from the Lower Tavern - picnic style at the Eastsound Waterfront Park
Farm-to-Table Excellence
The island is dotted with organic farms that supply fresh, locally grown ingredients to the island's restaurants. This commitment to local sourcing means that many menus change with the seasons, offering a culinary experience that's fresh, sustainable, and deeply connected to the area.
Conclusion:
So, if you're a food lover seeking a unique culinary adventure, Orcas Island is the place to be. With its fresh, local ingredients, diverse culinary offerings, and stunning natural beauty, Orcas Island offers a dining experience that's as unforgettable as it is delicious. So why wait? Come savor the flavor of Orcas Island – your taste buds will thank you!